Scandalous Stories, Great Cocktails

There’s something inherently captivating about a well-told secret shared over a stiff drink. At Scandal and Spirits, held at Second Act Spirits in the historic Amsterdam Clocktower in Amsterdam, NY, we’ve crafted a great evening by blending curated tasting experiences with narrative storytelling that keeps you on the edge of your seat. Each month, we offer a selection of curated cocktails that serve as the centerpiece for a journey through infamy and intrigue.

We serve

The Best Adult Storytime You’ll Ever Have!

Scandal and Spirits: The Naughty List Volume II, Fridays, December 11 and 18, 2026 at 6PM, Second Act Spirits, Amsterdam NY

Scandal and Spirits: The Naughty List Volume II

New Names. Old Scandals. Absolutely No Silent Nights.

You didn’t think we found all of Amsterdam’s naughty residents last year, did you?

Back by popular demand, Scandal and Spirits returns with another round of historical holiday mischief! We’ve checked the list twice, dug a little deeper into the archives, and uncovered even more of the Rug City’s questionable characters, scandalous secrets, and spectacularly bad decisions.

From forbidden romances and hometown scandals to crimes and general bad behavior, we’re raising a glass to the folks who made Amsterdam’s history a little less holy.

Dress Code: Naughty or Nice! Holiday glam encouraged. Velvet, lace, leather, glitter, halos, devil horns, ugly sweaters, or your best “I was just involved in a Victorian scandal” outfit.

Admission includes your first cocktail from our specially curated holiday cocktail list.

Fridays, December 11th and 18th, 2026 at 6PM

Click for TICKETS

Scandal and Spirits Election Day special: Ballots, Booze & Bad Behavior, November 3, 2026

Special Election Day Edition!

“Ballots, Booze & Bad Behavior”: An Election Day Scandal and Spirits Special

Amsterdam has never needed an election year to get messy. Join us for an Election Day edition of Scandal and Spirits featuring questionable candidates, political shenanigans, local scandals, audience voting, campaign nonsense, and plenty of opportunities to exercise your civic duty… with a drink in hand.

The polls are open. The standards are low.

Unlike real politicians, this event actually delivered on its promises.

Tuesday, November 3rd, 2026

PAST EVENT

Fatal Attractions: Love, Betrayal & Murder in the Rug City event poster

Fatal Attractions: Love, Betrayal & Murder in the Rug City

In old Amsterdam, love was blind—but the neighbors certainly weren’t.

Join local historian and storyteller Audrey Egelston for Fatal Attractions: Love, Betrayal & Murder in the Rug City, an evening of forbidden affairs, jealous lovers, suspicious spouses, and romantic decisions with very permanent consequences.

Expect scandal, shocking revelations, competing theories, and plenty of evidence that Amsterdam has always been terrible at keeping secrets.

Optional dress-up: Wear black, red, vintage date-night attire—or whatever you’d wear to a murder trial.

Scandal and Spirits:Everyone Was Watching event poster

Everyone Was Watching!

In a small city like Amsterdam, nothing stays private for long…but in the 1890s, it went beyond gossip—scandals were a spectator sport!
Explore the strange, dramatic, and sometimes tragic stories that had the whole town talking (and literally leaving their homes to watch)…from questionable taverns to love triangles, suspicious deaths, and even a Victorian-era “sugar daddy” funding the chaos
Dress Code (Optional): Victorian Wealth & Questionable Decisions

Fri. June 26th, 2026 – SOLD OUT

Scandal and Spirits:It Always Starts Small event poster

It Always Starts Small…

A secret that feels manageable.
A decision that seems fine at the time.
And then… it isn’t.

This is the night where things don’t just go wrong…they (spoiler alert) pick up speed faster than a sled down Glen Avenue.

Scandal and Spirits:Love Gone Wrong event poster

Love Gone Wrong

In an era of boarding houses, train schedules, strong opinions, and newspapers that printed everything, this program looks at what happened when people followed their hearts… and immediately regretted it. Expect impulsive choices, promises made too quickly, situations that escalated unnecessarily, and the timeless realization of “this seemed like a good idea at the time.”

PAST EVENT – SOLD OUT

Guests enjoying an evening at Second Act Spirits

noun


  1. An event or action regarded as morally or legally wrong and causing general public outrage
  2. the outrage or anger caused by a scandalous action or event
  3. Malicious gossip or talk about the private lives of others…….
    ………..often involving rumors of disgraceful behavior

We Open The Doors at 6PM.

The story starts a little later after our guests have ordered their cocktails. More than just a tasting event, these evenings serve as a portal to the past, where the atmosphere is charged with the glamour and intrigue of bygone eras.

A Scandal and Spirits storytelling and cocktail evening at Second Act Spirits
Scandal and Spirits guests in historical and vintage attire

We are inspired by our guests….

many of whom fully embrace the theme by donning historically appropriate attire—from Gatsby-esque finery to Victorian-inspired ensembles. Whether you arrive in full vintage regalia or simply a modern nod to the past, your presence adds to the immersive storytelling and spirited community that makes every event a night to remember.

A bottle of Clocktower Bourbon

Premium Stories & Cocktails

Events happen monthly and are ticketed to ensure everyone gets a seat.

Purchase tickets for upcoming events by clicking on the event image